Thursday, May 29, 2008

Tart Cherry Pie Recipe

Summertime means to me a time to enjoy good food, picnics, and lazy days and what better way to start off summer than to bake a cherry pie!

I don't know how many of you are fortunate enough to live near a cherry orchard. But I did, for a time. My home in South Bend, Indiana was 10 minutes from the Lehman Orchard in Niles Michigan which had a grove of tart cherry trees. Every summer around the 4th of July holiday I picked cherries at the Lehman Orchard and used them to bake a fresh cherry pie.

I really loved picking cherries and it was something I looked forward to every year. It's fun to pick cherries. You are sent out into the orchard with a bucket and the trees that are ready for harvest have ladders placed against their trunks . The cherries look like rubies hanging from the branches and warmed by the sun they are fairly bursting with the taste of summer. I know this because occasionally I would pop one into my mouth! Most of the time I would be completely by myself except for the occasional family that had come to make a day of it. I loved hearing the distant sound of children laughing and the overall lazy pace of slowly filling my bucket with the juicy cherries.

Generally a couple of hours was enough time to pick enough for a pie and I would then report to the pitting shed where they dumped my cherries into a machine that pitted the cherries within a matter of seconds! The machine is very archaic in appearance and rather what I imagine it must have been like to see a cotton gin at work.

I am no longer fortunate enough to live near a cherry orchard, but I still love a baked cherry pie. Being the soul of flexibility that I am, I now simply use jars of morello cherries and, even though there is no comparison to using fresh cherries, I still love it.

Here's the recipe that they give out at Lehman's Orchard, Michigan - along with my notes for using jars of tart morello cherries for those who aren't fortunately enough to live near a tart cherries orchard.  Oh, and do serve with a vanilla ice cream on top!

Cherry Pie Recipe

Basic 9" Pie Crust (this is my basic pie crust recipe)
2 ½ C. all purpose flour
1 tsp. salt (scant)
2 Tbs. sugar
1/2 C. Crisco vegetable shortening (buying it in the premeasured cubes makes measuring a lot easier)
1/2 C. unsalted butter
Approx. 5-6 Tbs. ice cold water/white vinegar mixture (fill a small bowl with ice water and splash in some white vinegar into the mixture - you will be adding the water/vinegar mixture 1 Tbs. at a time when mixing the dough)
1 egg white (for brushing pie crust top)
Sugar for garnish

Cherry Pie Filling

4 C. fresh tart cherries (if you don't live where you get tart pie cherries you can substitute Trader's Joe's Morello cherries in a light syrup (I use 2 jars - drained reserving 1/4 cup of juice to use with pie)).  Whatever you do don't use canned "pie filling" or sweet cherries
3 Tbsp. Tapioca
1 1/3 C Sugar (Note: if you are using Trader's Joe's Morello cherries reduce the sugar to 1 cup)
1/4 tsp almond extract
1 Tbs. unsalted butter (to dot on top of filling once it is in the pie shell)


Make Pie Crust

1. Combine flour, salt, and sugar.
2. Cut in shortening and butter.
3. Add water/vinegar mixture 1 Tbs. at a time. Use a fork to blend/mix just until the mixture forms a dough.
4. Divide dough in half and wrap each half separately in wax paper – let rest in refrigerator while you prepare filling and for a minimum of 10 minutes.

Prepare Filling

1. Drain Cherries (Note: reserve 1/4 to 1/3 cup of the juice if using jars of morello cherries - if you are using fresh cherries they have enough natural juices so that you don't have to reserve any juice)
2. Toss cherries with tapioca, sugar, almond extract (and reserved juice if using canned cherries). Let mixture stand 15 minutes.

Roll out Pie Crusts

1. Flour your work space. Roll out bottom pie crust. I like to roll out the dough on parchment paper as this helps prevent sticking. Wrap the crust around your rolling pin to transfer crust to the pie pan as this seems to help prevent tearing of the dough.
2. As there is a lot of juice in this pie you can sprinkle a little sugar and flour on the dough before adding the filling.  I usually add the cherries and then pour in enough juice to just about cover the cherries.  Dot mixture with 1 Tbs. unsalted butter.
3. Roll out top pie crust. Cover cherry mixture and decorate crust with leftover dough. Make 4 slits to release steam.
4. Brush pie crust with egg white and sprinkle generously with white sugar.


1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees.
2. After 20-30 minutes check to see if pie crust is golden brown – if it is – or when it becomes so – cover pie loosely with aluminum foil to prevent over browning/burning.
3. Continue baking for another 35-45 minutes or until juice is bubbling. Total baking time is generally 65-75 minutes.

Mr Puffy's Special Day

Poor Mr Puffy has been sadly neglected lately as we have been so busy with work. Not that he would complain. To make it up to him we gave him a little extra spoiling this past weekend. He began his special day with a relaxing massage. Only his daddy knows how to give a massage just the way he likes it! He also enjoys the male bonding time.

And since Mr Puffy also enjoys special treats - it wouldn't be a special day without a special treat! For his special treat I made him the brownie mix for dogs that he received as a Christmas gift from his good friend Ralph (a german shephard who lives next door). He's also anxious to try some of the treats from The Ultimate Dog Treat Cookbook a surpise gift from his pals Mosby and Roscoe who have the most generous mommy in the whole world (Rosanne at Firefly Nights) who knows a thing or two about tea, tea goodies, and tea etiquette!

Speaking of Tea Etiquette....

It is not proper tea etiquette to allow your tongue to loll out in anticipation of a treat while you wait for tea to be served. Parenthetically, do we occasionally have to speak with Mr Puffy about this.

On the other hand, it is proper tea etiquette (and perfectly understandable) to smile broadly as one patiently waits to be served a special treat that is still warm from the oven!

I think he liked the brownies. He certainly ate them enthusiastically.

I hope this is the start of a wonderful summer for everyone (and includes at least one picnic).


SissySees said...

What a delightful post!! And as a fellow brownie lover, might I suggest that your camera merely captured an instinctive moment, as Mr Puffy was about to lick his lips in anticipation???

jillian said...

Oh, my, goodness. Does that pie look yummy. Cherry pie is my favorite!

I didn't pick cherries growing up, but we picked apples and blueberries every year.

amanda said...

Thanks for the recipe - I've tried making pie crusts once and it was a disaster. I didnt have the right tools. I've used Pillsbury crusts since, but my MIL gave me a nice food processor for christmas, so I'lll have to try again.

I seriously laughed out loud about the comment on Mr Puffy's tongue. Ah, doggies!!

Monika said...

My mouth was watering while I read this post. I love, love, love fresh cherries! Not so much cooked, wether it's baking or for marmelade, but I'll eat it too. The pie looks so delicious. Mr. Puffy is so lucky, getting a massage and those yummy brownies! :o)

Firefly Nights said...

The pie looks great, the plate the pie slice is on is lovely, and your description of cherry picking was quaint and appealing. But, as usual, Mr. Puffy stole the show. He's such a darling boy. He must have been working out lately. He's looking much younger! My Roscoe could take him on in the smile for a treat category although it would be quite a match between the two. Roscoe has a silly doggie grin, and when he REALLY wants what someone is eating, he carries his ears out like airplane wings. Makes him look like The Flying Nun. Probably no chance of ever getting a photo since he's still apprehensive about cameras and changes his expression upon seeing one. Say hello too Mr. Puffy from all of us.

Firefly Nights said...

Sorry about "too" instead of "to" in the previous.

Anonymous said...

we used to pick cherries when I was a child...the pies seemed to be so much better...your crust looks perfect...and Mr. Puffy...what a good boy,he looks like he really enjoyed his treats!

Bridget said...

Oh I really enjoyed this post! Except I would have gladly sold my soul for a piece of that pie, it looked so good. Pie-baking is not one of my strong suits, le sigh.

I love the Mr Puffy pictures - it looks like he rather enjoyed his special attention and treats. We should all have such days!

Hilary said...

Yummmmm....thanks for the recipe! My parents have a couple of cherry trees at their house and I miss being able to just walk outside and pick the fruit. They still hook me up, though, when they come to visit!

The pictures of Mr. Puffy are precious! I love the one of him getting his massage -- so cute!

dogwithbooks said...

Oh Mr. are just about the greatest Puffy there is :)

Anonymous said...

Hi again, Claudia -- I'm the Ohioan. I grew up eating sour cherry pastries (thanks to my grandmother) and never see them anymore--thanks for the recipe!

Anonymous said...

I've never had a fresh cherry pie. I've always made it using the canned tart cherries. It's so good. I can't imagine how much more delectable it must taste with fresh cherries.

Mr. Puffy is such a lucky dog.

Mr Puffy's Knitting Blog: said...

Hi Kathy (the Ohioan! I love that this post reminded you of the sour cherry pastries made by your grandmother. I hope you give the recipe a try (and it lives up to your memories) oh and do make sure to serve it with icecream!

knittingdragonflies said...

Great post, just in time for me to make this pie for a party I am going to!
Love all of the pictures! And as always Mr. Puffy steals my heart.

Windyridge said...

My rhubarb is just about ready for making into a pie. I can't wait. Cherries are especially good for arthritis I am told.

Mr Puffy's is just the cutest with those ears laying flat.

kasiaiscarly said...

"Can she bake a Cherry pie, Billy Boy, Billy Boy" :)

What were you doing in South Bend? Those of us in Ann Arbor are typically not such fans of the Irish!

And nothing makes me smile more than a beagle smile. Jimmy Ray sometimes smiles so big he shows his teeth!